League: NFL Sport: Football Country: United States Category: Scores & Results

Craig Carton critiques Troy Aikman's status as an elite quarterback

Yahoo Sports • 1 min read • Latest: Aug 27, 2026, 3:32 AM

Last updated Aug 27, 2026

Craig Carton critiques Troy Aikman's status as an elite quarterback

Summary

FOX analyst Craig Carton publicly questioned Troy Aikman's legacy as a Hall of Fame quarterback during a recent segment on WFAN. Carton characterized Aikman as an 'average quarterback,' attributing his success to team strengths rather than individual skill. He cited Aikman's less-than-elite statistics, highlighting his career averages of 7.0 yards per attempt and a completion rate of 61.5%. Despite Carton's critique, former players, including Emmitt Smith, defended Aikman's contributions and highlighted his leadership and accuracy. The ongoing debate underscores the complexities in evaluating quarterback greatness.

Source Links

Yahoo Sports

By the Numbers

•Craig Carton labeled Troy Aikman an 'average quarterback.'
•Carton pointed to Aikman's supporting cast during his career.
•Aikman holds three Super Bowl rings and is a Hall of Famer.
•Emmitt Smith defended Aikman's legacy, citing his leadership and team success.
•The discussion highlights differing perspectives on defining quarterback greatness.

Latest Updates

3:32 AMYahoo Sports — “Troy Aikman Was an Average QB”: FOX Analyst Takes Brutal Shot at Cowboys Legend’s Legacy

What they're saying

"
FOX’s Craig Carton didn’t hold back when discussing Troy Aikman’s legacy. Many consider the Hall of Famer one of the greatest quarterbacks of his generation, pointing to his three Super Bowl rings as proof.
— Yahoo Sports

Related Teams & Leagues

Cincinnati Bengals Dallas Cowboys Jacksonville Jaguars NFL Football