League: NFL Sport: Football Country: United States Category: Scores & Results

Craig Carton's comments on Aikman and Mahomes draw fan backlash

Yahoo Sports • 1 min read • Latest: Aug 27, 2026, 6:59 AM

Last updated Aug 27, 2026

Craig Carton's comments on Aikman and Mahomes draw fan backlash

Summary

Craig Carton faced significant criticism for his remarks on Troy Aikman and Patrick Mahomes during his show on August 27. Carton questioned Aikman's legacy and suggested Mahomes might not be a star if drafted by a weaker team. His comments sparked outrage on social media, with fans and analysts dismissing his assessments as lacking historical context and data credibility. Prominent voices in the NFL community quickly responded, defending the accomplishments of both quarterbacks while scrutinizing Carton's arguments. The debate continues as fans discuss the merits of Carton's views online.

Source Links

Yahoo Sports

By the Numbers

•Carton questioned Aikman's status among NFL's greats.
•He implied Mahomes' success depends on team fit.
•Fans and analysts criticized Carton's arguments online.
•Historical context was cited in responses to Carton.
•Debate about player legacies remains active.

Latest Updates

6:59 AMYahoo Sports — ‘There’s a Reason His Shows Keep Getting Canceled’ — NFL Fans Outraged By Craig Carton’s Divisive Troy Aikman, Patrick Mahomes Hot Take

What they're saying

"
Craig Carton has never been afraid to make bold statements, but his latest take on two of the NFL’s most clinical quarterbacks sparked plenty of backlash. The sports talk host questioned Troy Aikman’s standing among the league’s greats, while also suggesting Patrick Mahomes may not have become a superstar if he had been drafted by a different team.
— Yahoo Sports

Related Teams & Leagues

Jacksonville Jaguars NFL Football