Dermot Gallagher discusses VAR call in Newcastle vs Aston Villa match

Dermot Gallagher, a former top referee, reviewed a controversial incident from the Newcastle United versus Aston Villa match held at St James' Park on October 17, 2026. In the game, Villa secured a 1-0 victory. Gallagher assessed a challenge made by Sven Botman on Nicolas Jackson, stating it warranted a red card rather than a yellow. He noted the challenge’s speed and intensity, implying it could have resulted in serious injury. Players and analysts shared mixed views on the incident, further emphasizing the need for clarity in VAR decisions.

• 10:39 AMYahoo Sports — Former top referee rules on controversial Newcastle United v Aston Villa incident