LeSean McCoy and Cam Newton critique NFL color commentators

Yahoo Sports1 min read • Latest: Sep 8, 2026, 11:30 AM

Last updated Sep 8, 2026

LeSean McCoy and Cam Newton critique NFL color commentators
Summary

Former FOX analyst LeSean McCoy and ESPN commentator Cam Newton recently voiced criticism regarding current NFL broadcast lineups. On the September 7 episode of Speakeasy, McCoy stated that Troy Aikman does not stand out as an analyst, despite acknowledging the Hall of Fame quarterback's resume and championships. This critique follows comments made by Newton on his talk show 4th & 1, where he questioned the selection process for mainstream color commentators. Newton expressed concern that the league's broadcast roles lack diversity, noting that a significant majority of players are minorities while those in the booth are predominantly Caucasian. He listed several analysts, including Kirk Herbstreit, Tom Brady, Tony Romo, and Cris Collinsworth, while suggesting that minority former players like Charles Davis, RGIII, Jonathan Vilma, and Jason McCourty are capable of filling these roles. Aikman, who serves as an advisor to the Miami Dolphins, remains the lead analyst for Monday Night Football.

Source Links
By the Numbers
  • LeSean McCoy stated on September 7 that Troy Aikman is not a standout television analyst.
  • Cam Newton criticized the lack of minority representation among lead NFL color commentators.
  • McCoy was fired from FOX in July 2025 following poor ratings for his programs.
  • Troy Aikman has served as the lead analyst for ESPN’s Monday Night Football since 2022.
  • Newton identified several minority former players who he believes are capable of holding broadcast positions.
Latest Updates
  • 11:30 AMYahoo Sports“I Don’t Think Troy Aikman Is That Great on TV”: Fired FOX Analyst Weighs In on Cowboys Legend’s ESPN Role After Cam Newton’s Criticism
What they're saying
"

Troy Aikman knows what makes a good NFL analyst. During an August 2026 appearance on Your Dark Companion with Mike Rhyner, he said one of the most important skills is knowing when to stop talking.

Related Teams & Leagues

Sources

External links

Original reporting and copyright belong to the linked sources. SportsNewsReport.com aggregates and links — it does not republish full articles.

Related Stories

Last 14 days