NFL analysts assess first-round rookie performance following completion of preseason schedule

NFL teams concluded their preseason slate, providing an evaluation window for the 2026 rookie class before the regular season begins. Raiders quarterback Fernando Mendoza finished with a C+ grade after logging 85 snaps, while Arizona running back Jeremiyah Love earned an A- despite sustaining a minor ankle injury. Other notable first-round picks received mixed feedback, including EDGE David Bailey and linebacker Arvell Reese, who both saw limited action. Wide receiver Carnell Tate struggled to connect on targets during his 35 snaps, resulting in a C grade. Coaches are now adjusting rosters and rotations to prepare these prospects for their professional debuts in the coming days. The preseason performance data serves as the primary indicator for team hierarchies and starter assignments for the season opener.

• 8:10 PMCBS NFL — 2026 NFL rookie grades: How Fernando Mendoza, Ty Simpson and every first-round pick performed in preseason