League: NFL Sport: Football Country: United States Category: Scores & Results

NFL fans criticize PFF for low grade on Bears QB Caleb Williams

Yahoo Sports • 1 min read • Latest: Sep 15, 2026, 2:35 PM

Last updated Sep 15, 2026

NFL fans criticize PFF for low grade on Bears QB Caleb Williams

Summary

Caleb Williams, quarterback for the Chicago Bears, had a standout performance in a 59-37 victory over the Carolina Panthers in Week 1. Williams completed 21 of 29 passes for 269 yards and four total touchdowns, showcasing strong execution. Despite this, Pro Football Focus rated him a 57.6, later adjusting it to 64.6, which has drawn widespread criticism from fans and analysts alike. Many argue that the ratings do not accurately reflect his high passer rating of 124.1 and leading QBR of 94.8, leading some fans to cancel their PFF subscriptions. PFF issued a damage control statement in response to the backlash, but the criticism continued.

Source Links

Yahoo Sports

By the Numbers

•Williams had 269 yards and four total touchdowns against the Panthers.
•PFF initially rated his performance at 57.6, later adjusting to 64.6.
•He led the NFL in QBR with a high score of 94.8.
•Critics claim PFF's grading system inaccurately reflects player performance.
•Many fans expressed their discontent on social media, leading to subscription cancellations.

Latest Updates