Premier League clubs face criticism for high-cost central midfielder signings
The Guardian Sport • 2 min read • Latest: Sep 3, 2026, 7:00 AM
Last updated Sep 3, 2026

Recent transfer market activity in the Premier League has drawn scrutiny regarding the rising costs of central midfielders. Manchester City completed a club-record £125m deal for Enzo Fernández, while other clubs have committed significant fees for players such as Sandro Tonali and Elliot Anderson. Critics question the comparative quality of these new arrivals against historical midfield standards, pointing to tactical shifts where players like centre-back Marc Guéhi see playing time in midfield roles ahead of established specialists. These signings are characterized by their versatility and reduced risk profiles, yet observers suggest the lack of elite, specialized attributes may not justify the record-breaking transfer fees. As clubs continue to pay premiums for these multifaceted players, the ongoing debate centers on whether the modern recruitment strategy is delivering sufficient quality for the substantial financial commitment involved.
- •Manchester City acquired Enzo Fernández for a club-record £125m.
- •Elliot Anderson previously moved from Nottingham Forest in a deal valued at £116m.
- •Marc Guéhi has been deployed in midfield roles for Manchester City this season.
- •Recent high-cost midfield signings include Sandro Tonali.
- 7:00 AMThe Guardian Sport — Premier League paradox: midfielders are more and more expensive, yet more and more mediocre | Jonathan Liew
"Enzo Fernández and Sandro Tonali had big-money summer moves, but can they hold a candle to past greats? Perhaps the only thing you really need to know about the modern midfield role is that Enzo Maresca reckons that Marc Guéhi can play it better than Mateo Kovacic. Guéhi, in reality a centre-back, started the season in midfield for Manchester City, ahead of Kovacic, the now-departed Nico González, and Matheus Nunes. In this context City’s purchase of Enzo Fernández for a club record £125m can be seen in one of two ways: either an enormous statement of intent, or a hell of a lot of money to pay for Guéhi’s understudy. We jest, of course. Fernández is in fact a very different kind of midfielder to Guéhi, largely on the basis that he actually is a midfielder. Versatile, able to receive deep from the goalkeeper or the centre-halves; capable of recycling or progressing the ball in tight spots, driving into final-third positions as a No 8, ghosting into the penalty area and offering an advanced goal threat. Like Elliot Anderson, signed from Nottingham Forest for £116m but so long ago that in transfer window time it no longer counts, Fernández is one of the new breed of Premier League central midfielders who seems to offer everything; albeit in modest qualities, and whose primary attribute appears to be the absence of exposed risk he represents. Continue reading...
Sources
External linksOriginal reporting and copyright belong to the linked sources. SportsNewsReport.com aggregates and links — it does not republish full articles.
Related Stories
Last 14 days
EPL•Sep 3, 2026, 7:00 AMHow pleased can Barcelona be with their transfer window?
EPL•Sep 3, 2026, 6:17 AMRanking the most game-changing transfers in Premier League history
EPL•Sep 3, 2026, 6:10 AMLiverpool replace Mo Salah with surprise move
EPL•Sep 3, 2026, 6:05 AMCity v Coventry: Matchday Live the ideal destination with no UK TV coverage
EPL•Sep 3, 2026, 6:01 AMHow much did your club spend? Premier League breaks transfer record
EPL•Sep 3, 2026, 5:45 AMJoao Pedro Delivers Perfect Response After Celebrating Against Former Club Brighton
