Soccer needs NFL-style red flags to improve VAR decisions

2 sources1 min read • Latest: Sep 16, 2026, 2:19 PM

Last updated Sep 16, 2026

Soccer needs NFL-style red flags to improve VAR decisions
Summary

The discussion surrounding VAR in soccer has intensified following controversy during the recent Manchester derby. A call for change suggests that the implementation of an on-field challenge system could prevent future disputes similar to those seen in the NFL. Advocates argue that adopting elements from American football's review process could enhance decision-making on the pitch. This debate comes amid ongoing criticism of VAR's effectiveness and the impact on game flow and fairness. There is potential for a significant shift in how soccer regulates contentious play if such changes are enacted.

Source Links
Key Details
  • VAR controversy arose during the Manchester derby.
  • Calls for on-field challenges similar to the NFL's system.
  • Criticism of VAR's current effectiveness continues.
  • Proposed changes aim to enhance decision-making in soccer.
  • Debate could influence future regulations in the sport.
Latest Updates
  • 3:00 PMESPNSoccer should learn from the NFL to fix the mess that VAR has created
What they're saying
"

Is it time to give the VAR the red card, or does soccer actually need the red flag? The Manchester derby controversy could have been avoided with an on-field challenge.

ESPNby Mark Ogden
Related Teams & Leagues

Sources

External links

Original reporting and copyright belong to the linked sources. SportsNewsReport.com aggregates and links — it does not republish full articles.

Related Stories

Last 14 days