League: NFL Sport: Football Country: United States Category: Scores & Results

Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy faces scrutiny as comparisons arise

Yahoo Sports • 1 min read • Latest: Sep 19, 2026, 4:47 AM

Last updated Sep 19, 2026

Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy faces scrutiny as comparisons arise

Summary

The Minnesota Vikings continue to evaluate their quarterback situation as J.J. McCarthy's performance draws scrutiny. After an injury-plagued rookie season, McCarthy has begun to develop since playing in 2025, although his stats reflect inconsistency. The Vikings reportedly kept him on the roster due to his contract situation. Phil Mackey from SKOR North suggested that the Vikings' approach to McCarthy's development could mirror the Packers' handling of their own quarterback situation. The Vikings are also considering trades as the Arizona Cardinals grapple with their quarterback challenges.

Source Links

Yahoo Sports

By the Numbers

•J.J. McCarthy's contract factors into Vikings' roster decisions.
•McCarthy recorded 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns in 2025.
•Phil Mackey compares McCarthy's path to the Packers' quarterback strategy.
•Arizona Cardinals reportedly interested in trading for McCarthy.
•Turner's development has been gradual but promising for the Vikings.

Latest Updates

4:47 AMYahoo Sports — Vikings Insider Makes Packers Comparison Over J.J. McCarthy

What they're saying

"
The Minnesota Vikings quarterback position is one that has been under tremendous scrutiny. Perhaps no one has been under more scrutiny at the position than J.J. McCarthy. The quarterback position itself is held to a different standard than other positions on the field. SKOR North’s Phil Mackey discussed this and how it applies to Dallas […] The post Vikings Insider Makes Packers Comparison Over J.J. McCarthy appeared first on HEAVY.
— Yahoo Sports

Related Teams & Leagues

Minnesota Vikings NFL Football